What Undecided Voters Look Like To Everyone Else
October 21
2020
Summary:
The episode uses a darkly comic doctor–patient dialogue to satirize how people weigh expertise against charisma, fame, and “outsider” appeal when making high-stakes decisions. As Mr. Thomas distrusts credentials and institutions, he’s swayed by a confident clown, conspiracy thinking, and emotional defiance even in the face of clear evidence that the trained surgeon is the only safe option. The conversation ultimately argues that flawed systems still require reality-based choices, and that rejecting competence for spectacle can compound harm and remove better options for everyone.
00:01
The Doctor
Mr. Thomas, I have some bad news.
00:09
You have a serious medical condition, and if you don't have surgery immediately, you'll likely die.
00:15
Mr. Thomas
Oh my God.
00:16
The Doctor
With your current health care plan, you can only choose between two people to do the surgery, but the choice is totally yours.
00:23
We have Dr. Stewart, a surgeon trained specifically in this procedure.
00:29
Or the circus clown.
00:34
Mr. Thomas
Wow.
00:36
Gotcha.
00:39
Where did the surgeon go to school?
00:41
The Doctor
You heard your options, right?
00:42
Yeah, I know, I know.
00:43
Mr. Thomas
It's just, this is my life we're talking about.
00:45
I just want to make an informed decision.
00:47
The Doctor
Well, um, it looks like Dr. Stewart went to undergrad at Purdue University.
00:52
Mr. Thomas
Purdue?
00:54
Not like a Harvard or the other one?
00:56
The Doctor
He did undergrad at Purdue, and then med school at NYU, and then residency at John Hopkins.
01:01
Mr. Thomas
Hmm.
01:03
And the clown?
01:05
The Doctor
Just a circus clown.
01:07
Not a surgeon, but it does look like this clown was best known for performing at Bartholomew and Bott's Big Ring.
01:15
Mr. Thomas
Oh my god, I've seen him.
01:17
He's kind of famous.
01:19
The Doctor
Yeah, he's clown famous.
01:22
Mr. Thomas
And the surgeon, he's not famous?
01:25
The Doctor
Well, he is very renowned in his field.
01:27
Mr. Thomas
But I wouldn't, like, recognize him from anything?
01:29
The Doctor
Anything being?
01:30
Mr. Thomas
I don't know, like a show or Instagram or TikTok.
01:34
No.
01:36
That's a lot of moving around.
01:37
The surgeon, a lot of moving around.
01:40
Purdue, the other places that you said.
01:43
The Doctor
Yes.
01:44
Mr. Thomas
So that's not suspicious to you?
01:46
The Doctor
No.
01:47
Mr. Thomas
I see.
01:49
So you're in on this?
01:49
The Doctor
In on what?
01:50
Mr. Thomas
I see.
01:53
And the clown, did he do a lot of moving around during his experience?
01:57
The Doctor
You mean his experience as a clown and not a doctor of any kind?
02:02
Mr. Thomas
Yes.
02:02
The Doctor
No.
02:03
He was mostly just a clown for the one circus.
02:06
Mr. Thomas
Hmm, solid track record then.
02:08
The Doctor
Okay, I feel like we're getting a little bit off topic.
02:10
You need the surgery to save your life.
02:13
And there is one doctor,
02:15
And one clown.
02:20
Mr. Thomas
Man, that clown is funny.
02:22
The Doctor
Mr. Thomas, this is a very serious decision.
02:25
Mr. Thomas
Right, of course, totally.
02:27
And just to make sure, does the surgeon have good morals?
02:32
The Doctor
Every doctor takes the Hippocratic Oath, which is a pretty strict ethical code.
02:35
Mr. Thomas
Well, that's very reassuring.
02:39
And the clown?
02:40
Is there some equivalency in the clown world?
02:43
No.
02:43
Are you sure?
02:44
Feels like there should be.
02:44
The Doctor
I'm not sure, but there would be no reason for clowns to have a moral code because they don't deal with life or death situations.
02:51
Mr. Thomas
Until now, that is.
02:52
Yeah.
02:53
So maybe they should fix that?
02:54
The Doctor
Or you could just have him not operate on you.
02:56
Mr. Thomas
For sure.
02:57
For sure.
02:58
It's just the surgeon is clearly a privileged elite.
03:02
The Doctor
Okay.
03:03
Mr. Thomas
So obviously that means that he worships the devil and he dissects baby squirrels.
03:08
The Doctor
There is no reason to think that the surgeon does any of that.
03:11
Mr. Thomas
But the idea is out there now, isn't it?
03:12
The Doctor
Because you said it.
03:13
Mr. Thomas
I know, but now that it's out there, it just feels so icky.
03:17
I'll be honest with you.
03:18
The Doctor
This clown has performed surgery before, and he has killed a lot of people.
03:23
Mr. Thomas
How many people?
03:24
The Doctor
Over 200,000 in the last eight months.
03:27
Mr. Thomas
Wow, that is a lot of numbers.
03:29
But maybe they would have died anyway?
03:30
The Doctor
But that's the point.
03:32
Probably a lot of people could have been saved with the proper surgeon.
03:35
Mr. Thomas
I'm leaning clown.
03:36
The Doctor
Why?
03:37
Mr. Thomas
The clown told me he could do the surgery.
03:39
And I don't know where you're getting your numbers, but the clown just gave me this very confident looking graph.
03:44
The Doctor
Oh my God, I can assure you.
03:46
He doesn't know how to do surgery.
03:48
He is a clown.
03:49
Mr. Thomas
So one of you two is lying to me.
03:51
How do I know that you're not the clown?
03:54
The Doctor
Because he's the clown.
03:56
Mr. Thomas
Fair.
03:57
He's very good at tricks, though.
04:00
The satanic squirrel dissector, does he do tricks?
04:04
The Doctor
You mean the surgeon?
04:05
He can do the very impressive trick of saving your life from all his years of training as a surgeon.
04:10
Mr. Thomas
It'd be pretty wild, though, if the clown did my surgery.
04:14
So crazy.
04:15
The Doctor
Yes, that would be crazy.
04:17
Mr. Thomas
I know.
04:17
He's not even trained.
04:19
The Doctor
Exactly.
04:19
This clown has no idea what he's doing, and if you don't get the surgery, you will die.
04:23
Mr. Thomas
Don't tell me what to do.
04:25
The Doctor
It's not telling you what to do if I'm just describing the facts of the world around you.
04:29
Well, don't describe the facts of the world around me if they're bad.
04:32
Mr. Thomas
OK, surgeon, clown, what are you going to do?
04:35
I don't know yet, but maybe if I yell enough, I'll figure it out.
04:38
You push me into this room and you put the weight of the world on my shoulders, and then you tell me that my only and obvious choice is this buttoned-up sucker, and then my only other option is this fake non-option, and you call me an idiot for doubting the integrity of the system itself?
04:52
Well, as I see it, that's the only reasonable thing to do in this fucked-up scenario.
04:55
And I don't know, maybe you're wrong!
04:57
Maybe there is some other choice!
04:59
Or maybe I can beat this thing on my own!
05:01
Or maybe you're lying to me and I'm not even sick!
05:04
Or maybe, just maybe, if I'm gonna die anyway, then my one mark on this stupid planet is to be the guy that got famous for having the world's most popular clown give him surgery!
05:14
Cause fuck it!
05:15
And fuck all of you!
05:16
And the clown told me he could do it!
05:19
Maybe he'll be great!
05:20
And cool!
05:22
The Doctor
I know this isn't easy or comfortable.
05:25
This is a very serious situation.
05:28
But there is hope.
05:29
There is a way out.
05:31
And yes, the system is flawed.
05:33
And you and I might agree or we might disagree on how it's flawed, but it is.
05:39
And that's why we need people like you to make it through the surgery so that you can make a difference and help change the system.
05:46
This clown doesn't know how to do surgery.
05:49
Mr. Thomas
I'm a great surgeon!
05:52
The Doctor
And if you let him, it's not gonna be good.
05:55
I promise you, he is bad and he is not cool.
06:00
And if enough people like you pick the clown, there might not even be a surgeon as an option next time.
06:08
I understand.